Fever Magazine

J.P. and Lily E’Lon give “Fallen Angel” time to find its duet

The Milwaukee artist’s new R&B EP, Between Who I Was, puts a two-voice ballad at the center of a particularly patient music video.

Simone Baptiste

J.P. and Lily E’Lon occupy the same house for much of the “Fallen Angel” video. Finding themselves in the same place is the easy part. The camera can give the audience a staircase and a dining room that already belong to both performers, while holding off on the moment the two share the frame as a pair. When the video finally brings them together, the song has had time to establish why a duet needs two people. There is a difference between having somebody available for a second verse and making a record that changes once the second person speaks.

“Fallen Angel” accompanies Between Who I Was, the six-track R&B release J.P. put out on November 20 through Roc Nation Distribution. The official video on his Vevo channel credits Daniel Goldstein as director, according to Kazi Magazine’s release coverage. Apple Music lists the project at 22 minutes. The small scale matters here. The most memorable idea from the video isn’t a succession of looks or locations. It is the decision to ask one property and two entrances to carry a story about how difficult it can be to meet somebody who is already close by. In the context of the EP, that feels like an unusually clear introduction.

An argument for keeping two people apart

An R&B video can sell chemistry by cutting straight to the satisfaction of being together. Goldstein’s arrangement, as Kazi describes it, gives the viewer the anticipation of recognition. A staircase does much of the work a page of dialogue might otherwise do. One person can be going somewhere while the other has already left. If you see both movements, you have enough information to know that the two characters are near each other. The possibility of a meeting hangs over a scene while the performers remain free to occupy their own time. There is a modest but important distinction between wanting an audience to see a couple and asking that audience to wait for one.

The long dining table is an even better vehicle for that idea. Normally a table gives people a place to sit together, even if the design also makes visible how much space exists between them. Putting two performers at opposite ends lets the film keep both things true. This is an ordinary domestic object doing unusual narrative work. The people are in sight of each other. The distance is still something they have to cross. That image gives practical shape to a quality already built into the duet form. Two people may be singing about the same relationship and working on quite different parts of it.

It is worth resisting the temptation to supply a complete story for the characters from what looks like a handful of deliberate images. The video gives us actions and physical separation. A song title can give us another angle on what those actions mean. There is no need to assign either singer’s part to an actual romantic relationship or to insist on a biographical reading of the EP. The staging leaves something for the performers to decide in each phrase. As long as that room stays open, the video can suggest yearning without turning the feature vocalist into supporting evidence for someone else’s life.

What J.P. already knew about timing

One useful reference point is “Bad Bitty,” the earlier track many listeners associate with J.P. That song’s dance circulation made it easy to encounter a brief presentation of a musician and feel as if it gave you the whole assignment. A hook that reads in a few seconds is a skill. A performer who can find the part of a phrase that a crowd will repeat has learned something important about how a line travels. On “Fallen Angel,” a related skill operates at the scale of a slower exchange. The payoff can be moved later. It doesn’t take away the power of the payoff. It makes anticipation a larger part of the experience.

Apple Music’s catalog situates the new EP among earlier singles including “Serenity,” “Freak Girl” and “Juicey Ahhh.” Even before taking an advertised shift in genre at face value, it is worth looking at how a catalog holds songs with different demands on a voice. A streaming preview or a social clip can put one bit of the catalog in circulation; a new release can make it easier to go through the others without thinking of any one as the only route in. Six songs in 22 minutes is a manageable amount of material for that kind of adjustment. It gives the artist room to set a new pace without asking for an afternoon.

Putting a duet into that sequence changes who gets to determine the pace. On a solo track, even a line that answers someone else generally has to establish both the address and the reply through one voice. E’Lon can give the reply an independent sound. She can also give a phrase enough space to keep its earlier meaning and to be heard differently by the time it comes back. A song might make that dynamic audible through a handoff. A video can make it tangible by allowing the two people to walk through the same rooms without each movement qualifying as a response. A collaboration designed this way has more texture than its two names on a listing.

The EP and the artwork tell different amounts

The title Between Who I Was reads like a description of an unresolved interval. It can be tempting to want the new songs to tell us exactly who the previous person was and where the next person should end up. The release information gives us a short R&B project and a key collaboration. The clip gives us a delay that has to be crossed in physical space. Both are good evidence for the kinds of decisions a listener can pay attention to, and they leave much of the personal interpretation to the work itself. Sometimes an EP title expresses a perspective more accurately by stopping early.

The useful thing about an EP is the precision with which a single can function inside it. With a longer album, one duet might be the standout listeners share while the other songs have to build an independent identity of their own. A six-track release makes each exchange matter a little more. “Fallen Angel” can give a reader a sense of the mood of the new project before that reader has deciphered every in-between feeling promised by the title. There is also time to recirculate the record on its own terms instead of stuffing the duet into a broad account of everything J.P. has made so far.

A distribution credit can suggest more than it actually proves. Apple Music’s listing carries a Roc Nation Distribution copyright line for the EP. That detail helps readers locate this edition of the release. It doesn’t establish which musicians or label staff were in a room for a given performance, and a release credit is a poor substitute for the individual creative roles shown elsewhere. The most direct way to follow the decisions in this project is to connect the work to the people whose jobs are visible. J.P. and E’Lon are the performers whose relationship carries the track. Goldstein is the director who had to translate it into rooms, entrances and exits.

The EP puts “Fallen Angel” second. “Peaches” comes first, and “Melrose Story” follows. Then come “How Does It Feel,” “Melodic” and “Good Times.” The official sequence gives the duet a position early enough to change what the listener might expect from the other songs, without making it perform every duty of an introduction. That helps explain why the music video and the EP can begin from different places. The video can present an idea of distance immediately. The record gives the audience one completed song before it asks the two singers to establish that distance on the second.

Start with the song, then watch the wait

For a first listen, the song and the clip can be heard as complementary versions. With the track alone, follow whose voice is moving a musical conversation forward, and take note of when there is enough room for another voice to come in. On the second pass, watch where the camera locates the two singers. The things you know about the house will get ahead of the things the characters know about each other. That discrepancy makes the reunion legible without a great deal of explanation. It also keeps a pair of singers from being treated solely as faces illustrating lines that have already been understood.

Then take the song back into the EP, where the first task is less about finding a narrative that explains every track than locating the patience against the other songs around it. A 22-minute project is short enough that the transitions can be experienced more than once. Listeners who came from J.P.’s earlier dance records can take that memory with them. The pleasure of the new duet has a little something in common with a dance hook after all. It knows an ending feels better when the people hearing it can sense where the moment is headed. It just chooses to let the two performers take their time getting there.